Every parent dreads it - holding the baby still while a nurse or technician pushes a needle into the tender flesh of a plump little thigh. The screams are bad enough - add the guilt at knowingly inflicting pain, even with the knowledge that a moment of discomfort is warding off death or weeks of illness.
But what if there was another way? What if a little clear patch arrived by mail, one that could be stuck onto the child's back and then would dissolve painlessly? Baby's protected, no one cries and everyone is saved the time and expense of an office visit. Several labs are working to make it happen.
Not only would it ease distress, but Dr. Erin Giudice, a pediatrician at the University of Maryland School of Medicine, thinks it might help fight a growing resistance to vaccination.
Obviously, for little kids vaccination is very scary and we come at them with a big needle every time they need a vaccine,- Giudice said in a telephone interview. "Having been around parents before and after their children receive multiple needle-based vaccines at the same time, I just can't imagine that some proportion of why some families decide not to vaccinate ... might have something to do with that we are giving some of these vaccines by a needle,- Giudice says.
Researchers for the government, for universities and at drug companies are all working to make this happen. Already a few needle-free alternatives exist - FluMist nasal spray, which vaccinates against flu with a squirt up the nose, is one. There are oral vaccines for cholera, typhoid and rotavirus.
The earliest vaccines were needle-free. Polio vaccine was once delivered orally - sometimes even on a sugar cube. And from ancient times, people inoculated one another against smallpox by scratching the skin and applying the scab from an infected person, or wiping a bit of cloth against a smallpox pustule and putting it into the nose. But these methods both only worked because they used a live virus - and they often infected people with the very disease they were meant to prevent.
New technologies may make it easier to design needle-free vaccines. One group got the go-ahead from the Food and Drug Administration to start testing a needle-free vaccine in people.
The Infectious Disease Research Institute (IDRI), a Seattle-based non-profit research group, has teamed up with a company called Medicago that works on vaccines using virus-like particles - little pieces of virus that can't cause disease but that stimulate the immune system the way a live virus could. It's delivered via a device made by Israeli company NanoPass using what are called microneedles.
Dr. Steven Reed, founder and president of IDRI, says it doesn't hurt and he thinks it will work better than standard, needle-delivered vaccines. He tried it himself.
'You just feel a little pressure - nothing else,' Reed says. The tiny device is covered with sharp little blades that scratch the skin. ?It is incredibly small. You can't even see it.? Reed says. It penetrates the first layer of skin, delivering the vaccine formula itself to immune cells called dendritic cells, which then pass it around the whole body to stimulate protection.
It's delivered with a needle-free syringe, and Reed believes it would be easy for people to administer it themselves, much like people with diabetes can inject themselves with insulin.
IDRI's vaccine is designed to protect against H5N1 avian influenza - the so-called bird flu that's been cooking in Asia, Africa, Europe and the Middle East since 2003 and that many scientists fear could mutate to cause a deadly pandemic in people.
Besides being painless and perhaps something that could be mailed to people, the vaccine should eventually be cheaper and easier to make than current flu vaccines, which must be incubated in eggs and take months to produce. ?Our main motivation, frankly, was to get superior efficacy by targeting the dendritic cells,- Reed says. It's grown in tobacco plants and uses a booster called an adjuvant, which makes a little vaccine go a long way.
"Our idea is to ultimately produce a one-dose vaccine that you could give yourself - imagine a flu vaccine that you can easily administer using a simple, painless microneedle device arriving in your mailbox,- said IDRI's Darrick Carter.
A similar approach has been developed at Georgia Tech, but it does away with the syringe. The microneedles are embedded in a patch that can be stuck on the skin until it dissolves. It's being tested against flu and polio.
The full article can be found here.
Although the dental industry does have needle-free delivery systems currently available, such as DENTSPLY Pharmaceutical's Oraqix, wouldn't it be cool if clinicians could provide anesthesia to patients by placing a sticky, dissolvable anesthetic patch on their gums, or if periodontal therapies could be administered using microneedles through the cheek? Pretty cool stuff!